PATRICK QUENTIN. Black Widow (1952).

11 Apr

It’s a classic noir set-up. A happily married man gets to feeling a bit lonely in his swank Sutton Place apartment after his wife leaves town for an extended trip. He wanders upstairs to a party thrown by his friends, and there he meets Nanny Ordway, a drab but plucky sprite who strikes a vaguely paternal chord in him. A friendship, wholly nonsexual, gels between them.BlackWidow.jpeg And then it all goes very wrong, very fast. His wife comes home, and in their bedroom the couple find Nanny’s dead body swinging from a chandelier. To Lieutenant Trant of the NYPD, to nosy neighbors and prying reporters, and perhaps even to the man’s wife, the scene suggests a suicide for which he’s morally to blame—the tragic upshot of a love affair gone sour. Which would be bad enough, but worse is his plight once Trant determines that someone strangled the girl; she didn’t kill herself, after all. A web of incriminating circumstance tightens around the man, a theatrical producer named Peter Duluth, and as he learns more and more about poor, demure Nanny, he comes to believe that she has woven that web, as if from the grave: “Nanny-spider,” he calls her. Duluth appeared in several earlier tales that cast him as a solver of urbane whodunits. But here he finds himself in Cornell Woolrich territory, a nightmare Manhattan where the routine amenities of big-city life (an all-night hamburger joint, a Bohemian bar in the Village, the tiny Murray Hill bachelor pad of an over-the-hill actor) take on a sickly sheen of doom and desperation. Quentin lacks Woolrich’s ability to construct an atmosphere of pure, frenzied claustrophobia. Yet he makes up for that flaw with a slick plot that delivers one, two, three twists of the narrative knife—really, it’s hard to count them—before freeing Duluth from the last dark strands of a spider’s handiwork.


Posted by on April 11, 2013 in American, Noir, Novel, Puzzle


3 responses to “PATRICK QUENTIN. Black Widow (1952).

  1. Cavershamragu

    April 12, 2013 at 1:47 AM

    I like Quentin (in this case Hugh Wheeler and, in his last collaboration, Richard Wilson Webb), but the boosk under that bykline are certainly less good on atmosphere than their ‘Jonathan Stagge’ books – but the plot and characters are very sound I think and the dialogue usually very plausible. Is FATAL WOMAN an a,lternate title for this one? Made into a decent movie, two years later:

    • Mike

      April 13, 2013 at 7:17 PM

      Sergio: Yes, I’ve seen that movie, and it is indeed an adaptation of “Black Widow.” (I’m fairly sure that the latter is the US title for the film.) The movie is a pleasant, well-mounted affair in its own right, but it alters the plot of the book in ways that undermine the effect that PQ is able to achieve in the novel.

      I like each of the.handful of books by Wheeler/Webb that I’ve read. The one Stagge title that I sampled (“Death’s Sweet Old Song”) is excellent. Other JS works are, alas, oddly hard to find.

      • Cavershamragu

        April 14, 2013 at 1:45 AM

        Stagge is not everyone’s particular brand of java – even the great Bill Pronzini in his 1001 MIDNIGHTS is uncharacteristically nasty about Stagge for instance, which really sticks out coming as it does from someone who is such a champion of the genre.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: