AARON ELKINS. Old Bones (1987).

12 Aug

The marshy ground by the bay at Mont St. Michel swallows up an old man as he finishes his hunt for seashells. Nearby, in the basement of a 16th-century Breton manoir, workers dig up the remains of another man. That pile of bones had lain underground for several decades—probably since the time of the Second World War, when Nazi Occupation troops and French Resistance fighters left a lot of bodies lying about. OldBonesPB.jpg In the vicinity, attending an international conference of crime investigators, is forensic anthropologist Gideon Oliver. He’s a more ordinary and agreeable fellow than his unofficial title, “the Skeleton Detective of America,” would suggest, and here he agrees to assist Inspector Joly in reconstituting the flesh of truth that clings figuratively to those old bones. Then another death occurs at the manor house, and attention turns to members of the du Rocher clan, the ancient grande famille that owns the place. The du Rochers, harboring the usual complement of intra-family secrets and resentments, present Oliver and Joly with a full slate of suspects.

In 1988, judges for the Mystery Writers of America organization gave this solid country-house whodunit an Edgar award for best novel of the previous year. Certainly, it has a plot of high caliber: Beneath the interconnected trio of mysterious deaths lurk mysteries of human identity; in the case of at least one character, identity appears to shift like the watery sands near Mont St. Michel. Elkins, moreover, writes polished and even masterful prose. Only his blithe and overly “cozy” tone calls into question, ever so slightly, the judgment of those judges. Old bones and fresh killings are serious business, after all.


Posted by on August 12, 2010 in American, Novel, Puzzle


2 responses to “AARON ELKINS. Old Bones (1987).

  1. Yvette

    August 26, 2010 at 7:16 PM

    I loved this book when I initially read it a few years ago. Since then I’ve read almost all the Gideon Oliver mysteries by Elkins. It’s funny because when he signs books for me he occasionally signs ‘ …to my biggest fan in New Jersey…” I get a kick out of that. But I think my favorite Aaron Elkins book is LOOT, a stand-alone he wrote a couple of years ago. I’ve reread it several times and never seem to get tired of it. Have you read it?

  2. Mike

    September 1, 2010 at 5:48 PM

    I haven’t read Loot, but on the slim basis of having read Old Bones, I can guess that Elkins would excel at writing a stand-alone thriller. I’ve actually read that only one book by him, and while I thought it was superbly done, the Gideon Oliver character came across as somewhat flat–a little too much so for a series character, I think. Elkins seemed, in that work, to enjoy painting on a broad canvas (e.g., those scenes at Mont St. Michel, etc.) more than he did sketching a memorable portrait of his hero. So a big one-off novel might showcase his talents more effectively. Anyway, I’ll be looking for a copy of Loot …


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: